Trucking scams: How brokers and carriers can protect themselves

December 22, 2025
Lightspeed

The trucking industry is a cornerstone of Canada’s economy, responsible for efficiently moving goods across provinces and borders. However, as the industry grows, it also attracts scammers targeting both brokers and carriers. From fraudulent freight brokers to fake load offers, trucking scams can result in substantial financial losses, damaged reputations, and operational disruptions.

1. Understanding the Common Types of Trucking Scams

Trucking scams take many forms, often targeting the most vulnerable points in the supply chain. Some of the most common types include:

a. Freight Broker Scams

Fraudulent brokers pose as legitimate freight intermediaries. They may offer high-paying loads but require upfront fees, fake contracts, or sensitive business information. Once the carrier commits, the broker disappears, leaving the carrier unpaid and potentially exposed to identity theft.

b. Fake Load Scams

In this scenario, scammers post fake load offers on load boards or email carriers directly. They often provide convincing documentation, including fake bills of lading, purchase orders, or invoices. When the driver delivers the cargo, payment never arrives, and sometimes the goods themselves are stolen or unrecoverable.

c. Payment & Factoring Scams

Factoring companies offer quick payment solutions by buying your invoices at a discount. Some scammers impersonate legitimate factoring companies to gain access to your accounts receivable. Carriers may end up transferring funds to fraudsters, thinking they’re receiving legitimate payments.

d. Cargo Theft Schemes

Some scams involve “phantom” shipments, in which carriers are tricked into delivering goods that don’t exist. Others may involve hijacking, misrouting, or redirecting cargo to fraudulent addresses.

e. Overpayment & Refund Scams

In these scams, a fraudster “overpays” for a load and requests the carrier to wire back the difference. Once the wire is sent, the original payment is reversed or invalidated, leaving the carrier at a significant loss.

Understanding these scams is the first step toward protecting your business. Knowledge empowers brokers and carriers to recognize red flags before it’s too late.

2. Red Flags That Indicate Potential Scams

Brokers and carriers should watch for warning signs that a transaction or load might be fraudulent. Common red flags include:

Unusually high rates for simple or short-haul loads
Requests for upfront fees or deposits to secure a load
Pressure to act quickly or bypass standard verification
Email addresses, phone numbers, or websites that appear unprofessional or temporary
Brokers who avoid providing references or business credentials
Requests for wire transfers, prepaid cards, or gift cards as payment

By training staff to recognize these signs, companies can reduce the likelihood of falling victim to scams.

3. How Carriers Can Protect Themselves

Carriers are particularly vulnerable because they often operate as independent contractors and may lack large support teams. To stay safe:

a. Verify Broker Credentials

Before accepting a load, carriers should confirm the broker’s legitimacy. This can include:

Checking MC numbers (Motor Carrier numbers) with Transport Canada or FMCSA in the U.S.
Reviewing customer reviews and online reputation
Requesting references from other carriers

b. Use Established Load Boards

Reputable load boards vet brokers and shippers to reduce the risk of scams. While scammers can still appear on these platforms, using trusted boards significantly lowers risk.

c. Implement Clear Payment Terms

Never accept a load without clearly defined payment terms. Written contracts and invoices should detail:

Payment method
Payment timeline
Responsibilities in case of delays or cargo damage

Factoring companies should also be verified directly to ensure legitimacy.

d. Protect Sensitive Information

Avoid sharing unnecessary financial or personal information, such as bank account details or social security numbers, until the broker’s legitimacy is verified.

e. Train Drivers and Staff

Driver awareness is critical. Training programs, including compliance and safety training, can help drivers recognize suspicious transactions and understand the proper reporting procedures.

4. How Brokers Can Protect Themselves

While carriers are often targeted by load-related scams, brokers also face risks such as identity theft, fake carrier profiles, and fraudulent insurance claims.

a. Verify Carrier Insurance and Licensing

Ensure carriers are properly licensed, insured, and compliant with federal and provincial regulations. Request documentation and verify through official databases to prevent fraudulent operations.

b. Perform Background Checks

Brokers should verify carriers’ operational history, safety ratings, and customer reviews. This reduces the likelihood of hiring a fraudulent operator.

c. Use Secure Payment Systems

Avoid paying or receiving funds through untraceable methods. Payment should always be through traceable channels, such as wire transfers, ACH payments, or trusted factoring services.

d. Educate Staff on Scam Awareness

Internal education helps prevent accidental fraud. Brokers should train employees to spot suspicious carriers, phishing emails, and unusual payment requests.

e. Implement Fraud Detection Tools

Many modern transportation management systems (TMS) offer fraud alerts, tracking tools, and verification protocols. Investing in these tools reduces risk and builds trust with carriers.

5. Reporting and Legal Recourse

Despite precautions, some scams are inevitable. In these cases, quick action is essential.

a. Report Fraud to Authorities

In Canada: Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre (CAFC)
In the U.S.: Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) and local law enforcement

Reporting helps authorities track patterns, warn the industry, and potentially recover funds.

b. Notify Banks and Payment Providers

If a fraudulent transaction involves your bank or payment provider, report it immediately. They may be able to freeze funds or reverse unauthorized transactions.

c. Document Everything

Maintain detailed records of all communications, invoices, contracts, and emails. Clear documentation can support legal action or insurance claims.

6. Leveraging Technology for Scam Prevention

Technology has become an essential defense against trucking scams. Both brokers and carriers can benefit from:

TMS software: Tracks shipments, verifies carriers, and flags suspicious activity
ELD (Electronic Logging Devices): Confirms driver logs and prevents false claims
GPS and load tracking: Provides real-time visibility to prevent cargo theft
Fraud detection tools: Monitor unusual transactions and patterns

By combining vigilance with technology, companies create a multi-layered defense against potential scams.

7. Best Practices to Minimize Scam Risks

Implementing strong policies and consistent practices can significantly reduce exposure to fraud:

Always verify parties before transactions.
Use trusted load boards and brokers.
Keep all agreements in writing.
Train staff and drivers on scam awareness
Conduct regular audits of payments, insurance, and licensing.
Maintain an incident response plan in case fraud occurs.

Following these practices fosters a culture of safety, compliance, and accountability.

8. Why Awareness Matters

The trucking industry is heavily reliant on trust. Every transaction, load, and payment involves risk. Scammers exploit any weakness, from inexperience to rushed processes.

By staying informed about common scams and implementing robust verification procedures, brokers and carriers can:

Protect financial assets
Safeguard the company’s reputation.
Avoid operational disruptions
Enhance driver and staff confidence.

Even a single lost load or fraudulent payment can be costly, making prevention far more economical than remediation.

9. The Role of Industry Training

Training programs play a critical role in preparing carriers and brokers against scams. Courses on compliance, safety, and fraud awareness help companies:

Identify high-risk scenarios
Implement effective verification procedures.
Educate drivers on reporting and preventive measures.

Conclusion

Trucking scams continue to evolve, placing brokers and carriers under increasing pressure to verify partners, protect cash flow, and maintain operational integrity. While no business can eliminate risk entirely, proactive awareness, disciplined processes, and the right safeguards can significantly reduce exposure to fraud. Staying informed is not just a defensive measure—it is a competitive advantage in today’s freight market.

AVAAL helps transportation professionals strengthen their risk management posture by delivering insights, tools, and solutions designed for real-world freight challenges. If your organization is looking to protect itself from bad actors, improve due diligence practices, and operate with greater confidence, we can help.